Ally Financial Inc. (ALLY) on Q4 2021 Results - Earnings Call Transcript

Operator: Good day and thank you for standing by. Welcome to the Ally Fourth Quarter and Full Year 2021 Earnings Conference Call. At this time, all participants are in a listen-only mode. After the speakers’ presentation, there will be a question-and-answer session. Please be advise that today’s conference is being recorded. I would now like to hand the conference over to your speaker today, Daniel Eller, Head of Investor Relations. Please go ahead. Daniel Eller: Thank you, Jiji. And welcome, everyone, to Ally Financial’s fourth quarter and full year 2021 earnings call. This morning, we have our CEO, Jeff Brown; and our CFO, Jen LaClair to review Ally’s results before taking questions. I will note that the presentation we will reference on today’s call can be found on the Investor Relations section of our website, ally.com. Forward-looking statements and risk factor language governing today’s call can be found on slide two, and GAAP and non-GAAP or core measures pertaining to our operating performance and capital results are on slide three and four. These metrics are supplemental to and not a substitute for U.S. GAAP measures. Definitions and reconciliations can be found in the appendix. With that, I will hand the call over to JB. Jeff Brown: Thank you, Daniel. Good morning, everyone. And thank you for joining our call today to review fourth quarter and full year 2021 results. I will begin on slide number five. Ally generated outstanding results in 2021. I’m incredibly proud of the efforts and dedication of our more than 10,000 teammates who delivered yet another year of innovation and focused execution. Over the past few years, we’ve experienced a profound shift in consumer demand and expectations for seamless digital first banking products in response to COVID-related challenges and advancements in technology. Ally has leveraged these broad-based secular trends to strengthen our position as a disruptive growth company guided by a winning formula to do it right for our customers, employees and communities. Full year adjusted EPS of $8.61, core ROTC of 24.3% and revenues of $8.4 billion represented record setting results and evidence of the leading auto, insurance and digital bank platforms we built. Momentum generated across our businesses positions us well to continue unlocking franchise value in the years ahead. Our recent acquisition of Fair Square, the latest digital first capability we’ve added to our product suite will further enhance our trajectory. We close the transaction in December, ahead of schedule and are well underway with the integration. Looking at auto results, our dealer networks expanded for the 12th straight year in 2021, generating $46.3 billion of originations, our highest level since the early 2000 source from a record 13 million decision applications. This was our fourth consecutive year of origination yields above 7%, demonstrating our strong competitive position, disciplined underwriting, and leading dealer and customer service capabilities. Credit losses remained benign, with 31 basis points of full year retail auto net charge-offs. Our leadership position within the auto ecosystem is clear across these metrics, affirming the strength of our team and the success of our multi-prong strategy to broaden the dealer network and generate solid volumes and accretive risk adjusted returns. The strength and agility of our business model in a wide variety of operating environments is evident in our performance over the past two years, as we’ve successfully responded to strong consumer demand, high use vehicle values and reduced inventories. We’ve earned our market leading position by driving customer value over the long-term and we remain focused on achieving continued success as we navigate change in the years ahead. Across our consumer and commercial portfolios, credit remains very strong, supported by robust job prospects, ongoing wage expansion and the strongest customer balance sheets observed in decades, all of which help mitigate inflationary dynamics. While the pace of credit normalization remains up for debate, we’ve taken a balanced approach in our reserve process, under a view like normalization will occur gradually over the next two years. We proactively enhance the use of advanced data, automation and digital tools, increasing customer engagement, and strengthening our ability to mitigate losses. Between 40% and 70% of our auto customer interactions occurred digitally each month, increasing speed and effectiveness, while creating a strong customer experience. Within insurance, our compelling value proposition for dealers and consumers is evident in written premium volume of $1.2 billion for 2021, as we expanded dealers and customers. Our investment portfolio grew to $6.5 billion, a highest level since becoming a publicly traded company, reflecting years of steady written policy growth. Turning to Ally Bank, growth accelerated again this year, aligned with the increasing momentum toward a digital-first world. As the leading all digital and customer centric bank, we’ve established a scalable platform differentiated by the personalized, seamless modern banking products we’re delivering. We generated our 13th consecutive year of customer and balanced growth, as our customer base expanded 10%, while total deposits grew to 89% of funding. Within our digital-first consumer offerings, Ally Home originations of $10.4 billion were more than doubled the prior year level. Ally Invest customer assets exceeded $17 billion, as self-directed and robo accounts grew to 506,000. Ally Lending volume of $1.2 billion more than doubled and was powered by a 37% increase in merchant relationships across our healthcare and home improvement verticals. Fair Square balances close the year at $953 million, an increase of 25% since announcing the acquisition in October and 66% year-over-year, reflecting strong customer acquisition, consumer spending trends and the scalability of the Fair Square approach. And within Corporate Finance, HFI balances of $7.8 million grew nearly 30% year-over-year, through a combination of increased new loans in normalizing drawdown activity among our clients. The CF portfolio, including unfunded commitments, now stands at $12.7 billion, which highlights the success we’ve had in growing this business. As a result of our strong financial position, we were pleased to recently announce a $2 billion buyback authorization program for full year 2022 and a 20% dividend increase to $0.30 per share. As we turn to slide number six, I will reiterate the view I’ve shared on many occasions, regarding the link between values and results. I’m confident our record setting performance and ongoing momentum are directly tied to the clear focus and prioritization of our customers, employees and communities. Maintain maintaining an authentic and inclusive culture has been a top priority for me during my tenure as CEO. Ally took several actions over the past year, aligned with our Do It Right approach. For our customers, we’ve actively enhanced products, interfaces, and service capabilities, utilizing advanced tech and data innovations, which Jen will provide more detail on. We took the key step of adding a credit card product to our suite of digital-first offerings and we’re proud to lead the industry in eliminating overdraft fees, leading to bank on national account certification from the Cities for Financial Empowerment Fund. For our Ally teammates, we increase Ally’s minimum wage to $20 per hour. While we announced the third annual grant of company stock to all employees, and expanded health and family benefit programs. We were honored to be named among the Best Places to Work at Forbes, DiversityInc and numerous other publications, and received another perfect Corporate Equality Score from the Human Rights Campaign. Over 40% of our workforce voluntarily participates in one of our employee resource groups, the key elements of how we’re driving a stronger sense of belonging and engagement across our teams. Our deliberate actions to treat people as people and create an inclusive workplace have the added benefit of acting as a powerful retention tool. Within our communities, we marked our 10th year of the employee-led giving back campaign donating 24,000 hours of time to worthy causes. We hosted our third annual Moguls in the Making student competition, in partnership with several HBCUs and mark the first full year for the Ally Charitable Foundation Actions, donating $15 million of combined employee and company contributions to community, social and educational causes. On the ESG front, we announced Ally achieved carbon neutrality and officially established Environmental Sustainability Office. Taken in isolation, any one of these actions would represent a significant milestone. But when taken together, these actions provide clear evidence of what can be achieved when purpose, creativity and dedication come together under shared vision. Moving to slide number seven, I wanted to spend a few moments summarizing the strategic evolution we’ve delivered before handing it over to Jen to walk through the details. Over the years, we built resilient platforms through constant expansion and evolution of our customer centric offerings. We challenge ourselves each day to look around corners and embrace disruptive forces on behalf of our clients and customers to proactively manage risks and deliver financial solutions that anticipate their needs in a seamless differentiated manner. While performance was exceptional in 2021, the opportunities we built for growth in 2022 and beyond are what I’m most excited about, including continued momentum across our leading customer-centric businesses, delivering diversified and durable earnings, and disciplined capital management. These priorities have positioned us to deliver long-term growth and sustained higher returns, as seen in our track record of delivering or exceeding the financial guidance we’ve provided over the past several years. We continue to focus on deepening customer relationships through digital capabilities that combined leading award winning products with integrated, stable and secure bank platforms. We’ve got a really powerful model and considerable financial strengths. The future is bright and you can be assured we will keep delivering. With that, I will turn the call over to Jen to provide perspectives on our progress and review our detailed financial results. Jen LaClair: Thank you, JB, and good morning, everyone. I’d like to start by expressing my gratitude for our dedicated Ally workforce, who powered our growing momentum over the past several years and drove exceptional results in 2021. Before diving into the fourth quarter details, I will review Ally’s multiyear strategic and financial transformation, including the drivers behind our steady execution and strong performance. Beginning on slide eight, we’ve included a view of our comprehensive and expanded products read, reflecting the many capabilities we’ve added since 2014. We provide a broad range of integrated and sophisticated offerings built for and around our consumer and commercial clients. Turning to slide nine, we’re constantly evolving and adapting our capabilities innovating through tech and data driven approaches. With each new product launch, redesign or enhancement, we apply our deeply rooted expertise in disruptive DNA to create unique, safe and innovative solutions for a broad range of financing and banking needs. Our customer-centric approach focused on delivering compelling value, fills growth, creates opportunities for relationship deepening and diversifies Ally’s balance sheet and earning. Ally’s compelling growth trajectory and the customer oriented awards we’ve amassed over the years serve as a testament to the effectiveness of our approach. Turning to slide 10, customers using an Ally product now stands at 10.5 million across our platforms expanding 52% since 2014. Ally Bank customers have more than quadrupled over this timeframe, as we’ve evolved our capabilities and successfully expanded multi-product relationships shown on the bottom left. In auto, we’ve added nearly 5,500 dealers as part of our multiyear effort to broaden the funnel and increase dealer engagement. This strategy has culminated in a 40% plus increase in application volume, driving strong originations and risk adjusted return. Robust product expansion and customer growth have translated to improved balance sheet and earnings covered over the next few pages. Turning to slide 11, our balance sheet transformation reflects two key dynamics; first, the diversification of our asset base, which is grown by $31 billion or 20% since 2014. Over this timeframe, we’ve generated $23 billion or a five-fold increase in Ally Bank consumer and commercial product balances, $13 billion of consumer auto balances, helping to mitigate the pandemic-driven floor plan declines and nearly $14 billion in a creative capital efficient investment securities. The second driver of our optimization can be found within net interest margin shown on the bottom of the page, where disciplined asset pricing, deposit growth and active liability management have increased asset yields and improved funding costs. Auto pricing has remained above 7% for four consecutive years, while floating rate commercial and unsecured products are positioned for further growth and accretion as rates rise. On the funding side, we’ve more than doubled stable sticky deposits since 2014, while retiring $24 billion of legacy on secured debt with a weighted average coupon of over 5%. These actions drove structurally lower funding costs throughout the prevailing low rate environment and have enhanced our ability to control liability costs. In the years ahead, we expect our balance sheet to drive an upper 3% margin, as assets steadily migrate towards $200 billion. Structural enhancements across both sides of our balance sheet drove strong performance over the past two years and position us well for a variety of rates and economic environments moving forward. Turning to slide 12, Ally’s core PPNR has more than doubled since 2014, generating nearly $4.3 billion in 2021, our highest level. Our outlets for annual PPNR expansion will be revenue driven, as we continue to prudently invest in customer capabilities, technology, talent and brand. In the bottom left, total revenues of $8.4 billion represented record setting net financing revenue and other revenue, reflecting diversified sources of income and our ability to capture tailwinds in real time. In the bottom right, Ally’s adjusted efficiency ratio, which as a reminder, excludes insurance reached the lowest level since becoming a publicly traded company as we remain diligent and investment and expense management. Moving to slide 13, our disciplined and rigorous risk management approach has driven consistently strong credit outcomes. Consolidated net charge-offs have remained below 1%, while retail auto losses have outperformed our 1.4% to 1.6% guidance in six of the seven past years. These trends reflect the high quality, high utility of our loan and lease products, consistent disciplined underwriting capabilities, modernize collection and servicing practices, and more recently, tailwinds associated with stimulus and historically strong collateral values. As JB mentioned earlier, we expect credit to steadily normalize through 2023, which our reserve levels accommodate. Risk management is a key pillar within our strategic plan, as we applied deep experience, extensive data and sophisticated approaches in our assessment, pricing and servicing across our balance sheet. Turning to slide 14, our diligent focused on a creative capital deployment is reflected in our expanding returns and over 70% increase in tangible book value per share. Our capital strategy remains focused on long-term value creation, evident in our robust growth trajectory both organic and inorganic, as we’ve executed opportunistic tuck-in acquisitions to augment capabilities. This disciplined approach has resulted in $16 billion of RWA expansion, even while we’ve returned $6.5 billion an access capital to shareholders through buybacks and dividends. Current CET1 levels remain well above our internal and regulatory targets, a testament to our approach and the strength of our position moving forward. Now let’s turn to slide 15 to review detailed results for the quarter. Net financing revenue, excluding OID, of $1.66 billion grew 27% year-over-year, representing our highest quarterly results. Adjusted other revenue of $533 million reflected solid investment gains and growing momentum across our diversified product offering. Provision expense of $210 million included the day one reserve billed of $97 million associated with closing Fair Square and the seasonal rise in NCOs even as loss frequency and severity trends demonstrate continued strength. Non-interest expense of $1.1 billion was driven by actions highlighted over the past, including variable costs across our businesses from customer and revenue growth, investments in our brand, security and tech capabilities, and purposeful investment in our workforce and benefits, allowing us to drive employee engagement in the top 10% of all companies, a critical advantage for us as we navigate competitive labor markets. GAAP and adjusted EPS for the quarter were $1.79 and $2.02, respectively, both of which include $0.09 related to a state specific tax item and one month of Fair Square results. Moving to slide 16, net interest margin, excluding OID, was 3.82%, 90 basis points higher in prior year and our sixth consecutive quarter of expansion. Earning asset yield of 4.75% grew quarter-over-quarter, as we redeployed the earning cash in the higher yielding loans and investment securities. Average earning assets grew to $172.9 billion. Ending balances increased by over $6 billion, representing our strongest linked-quarter growth in over five years with all loan balances increasing. Turning to liabilities, cost of funds improved 8 basis points, the 10th consecutive linked-quarter decline. Ally continues to remain well-positioned for a variety of rate environments, as we’ve cultivated strong customer loyalty and engagement through our expanded suite of digitally-based products. We strengthen pricing and beta on both sides of the balance sheet and tactically utilize hedging strategies to bolster our overall asset sensitivity and NIM position. Turning to slide 17, CET1 of 10.3%, reflected risk weighted asset growth, including $3.5 billion of floor plan balances -- balance increases and the impact of closing Fair Square, which taken together represented 75 basis points of capital consumption. Despite these impacts, CET1 remains $1.9 billion above our internal target. We recently announced our second consecutive $2 billion buyback authorization and a 20% increase in our common dividends to $0.30 per share. Since the inception of our capital program in 2016, we’ve reduced shares outstanding by 30%, while increasing our dividend 7 times. The quality of our capital position has improved, as we’ve leveraged our investment grade rating and proactive liability management to bolster liquidity, funding and our financial profile. On slide 18, asset quality remained strong throughout Q4, as consumer and commercial losses remained historically low. In the upper left, consolidated net charge-offs of 35 basis points were nearly half prior year and 60% below 2019. Retail auto trends shown on the bottom reflected solid customer payment trends and improved loss given default rates supported by strong collateral values. Early and late stage delinquency trends reflected seasonal activity remaining well below prior year and 2019 levels, and encouraging signal heading into 2022. On slide 19, consolidated coverage of 2.67% reflected growth across our retail auto, point-of-sale and mortgage portfolios, plus the addition of reserves for Fair Square. Retail auto coverage of 3.54% move quarter-over-quarter by 8 basis points, as trends continue to improve across consumer health and macroeconomic measures. Blue Chip forecasts indicate unemployment levels will remain at approximately 4%. As a reminder, under our CECL reserve approach, we incorporate this outlook for full employment into our 12 months reasonable and supportable period before migrating to the historic mean of 6.5% by month 36. This methodology reflects the prudent approach we’ve adopted under CECL to manage uncertainty, minimize volatility and maximize transparency. Turning to slide 20, retail deposits ended at $134.7 billion, Q4 increased $3.1 billion, representing our sixth straight year of growth at or above $10 billion. New and existing customers continue to drive our performance, reflecting our compelling products and their desire to keep their money and grow their balances with us. We generated our 51st consecutive quarter of customer growth, adding 226,000 in 2021, while retention remains industry leading at 96%, as we launched our largest brand campaign to-date during Q4. On the bottom right, customer demographics show the compelling opportunity we have to deepen relationships, as nearly 70% of new customers are from younger generation early in their financial journey and with a high propensity for digital engagement. Turning to slide 21, our expanded product suite positions us for ongoing growth. We’ve generated six years of multi-product relationship deepening that continues to accelerate across all products. We’ve leveraged our large and growing depositors to build scale within each of these offerings and we’ve seen a steady increase in growth from customers who are new to Ally altogether. These trends reinforce the momentum of our brand, and the relevance and quality of our diversified digital platforms. Moving to slide 22, auto segments pre-tax income of $839 million reflects our adaptable leading business model. Revenue growth reflects the multiyear optimization of consumer and commercial lending strategies, in addition to tailwinds from strong credit and elevated used car values. We included retail portfolio trends in the bottom left, where origination yields were made above 7%, again in 2021, which we expect to continue as we generate over $40 billion of volume annually moving forward. On the bottom right, lease activity reflects the impact of record used car values, and elevated lessee and dealer buyout activity, which tempered realized gains in 2021. Within our financial outlook, we assume steady normalization of these trends, providing us yet another opportunity to demonstrate our ability to effectively navigate changes within the auto ecosystem. Within our financial outlook for revenues and credit, we’ve embedded an assumption for use bias to decline by 15% to 20% cumulatively by the end of 2023, even as recent trends indicate ongoing resilience. Execution within auto reflects our diversified full spectrum capabilities, expanded market reach, experienced underwriting and increased use of technology. Turning to slide 23, our agile adaptable platform enables us to source strong volume across a variety of environments. In the upper left, we generated $46 billion of origination volume in 2021, source from our network of over 21,000 dealers. And in consumer assets expanded to $89 billion, shown in the upper right, reflecting retail and lease portfolio growth, while ending commercial balances grew for the first time in five quarters, ending at $16 billion. This was driven by a 15% rebound in industry inventories, a modest, but positive trend occurring ahead of our expectations for growth later this year. Q4 auto originations of $10.9 billion represented our highest fourth quarters since 2004, while we’ve maintained a disciplined underwriting approach. Turning to our insurance segment on slide 24, core pre-tax income of $67 million, reflected investment gain activity, modestly below prior quarter results, but well above historic levels. In the bottom left, the $6.5 billion investment portfolio continues to add revenue generating capabilities, enhancing segment and consolidated returns. Total written premiums of $268 million, resulted in $1.2 billion of full year written premium, our fourth consecutive year above $1 billion. Overall, we are pleased with the resilient, countercyclical value of our insurance business and remain focused on more fully leveraging our large dealer network for future growth. Moving to slide 25, corporate finance core income of $75 million reflected revenue growth from meaningful year-over-year asset growth, strong investment and syndication income, and solid credit trends. HFI balances ended at $7.8 billion, the highest level on record for Ally, while unfunded commitments of $4.9 billion position us for ongoing expansion. Our portfolio is comprised of high quality, diversified loans built through steady, deliberate execution across our experience team. We remain confident in the continued discipline growth of this business moving forward. Mortgage details are on slide 26, where pre-tax income remained relatively stable during the quarter, as asset growth helped to mitigate normalizing gain on sale margins and persistently elevated prepayment trends. Ally Home originated $2.9 billion and direct-to-consumer volume in Q4, exceeding $10 billion for our full year 2021, well ahead of schedule. Having steadily grown our national reach over the past few years, we’ve improved our opportunity to generate strong volume, as we prioritize attractive return. I will wrap up on slide 27 with our financial outlook. We’ve consistently demonstrated earnings expansion and improved return through several years of execution. Our clear vision, priorities and strategy have positioned Ally to continue generating meaningful and sustained value in the years ahead. We expect ROTC of 16% to 18% plus over the medium-term, defined as the next two years to three years and beyond, as we further leverage our leading businesses and high quality balance sheets to drive financial performance. Notably, while our return targets do not depend on uniquely strong macro economic trends or pockets of transitory dynamics, we will remain opportunistic capturing upside beyond these ranges. Results will be fueled by revenue driven PPNR expansion derived from an upper 3% NIM profile and diversified revenue generation among our established and broadened consumer offerings. We’ve included several of the key variables and assumptions embedded within our forecast, including benchmark interest rates, credit expectations and used value -- used vehicle value trends. Based on the balanced approach we’ve taken in our outlook and the strong momentum across all our businesses, I am confident in our ability to consistently generate profitable growth, enhance book value and sustained return. And with that, I will turn it back to JB. Jeff Brown: Thank you so much. And I will close with just a few comments on slide number 28. Our purpose and cause will remain centered our customers, employees and communities. We build a profitable, compelling growth company by meeting customer needs through differentiated products and services. Ally has pivoted to an exciting era of growth. The dedication of our 10,000 plus Ally teammates, fuels my confidence in the ability we have to drive an even brighter future. And with that, Daniel, back to you and head into Q&A. Daniel Eller: Thanks, JB. So as we head into Q&A, I will ask participants to limit yourself to one question and one follow up. Operator, you can go ahead and tee up the first question. Operator: Our first question comes from the line of Ryan Nash from Goldman Sachs. Your line is now open. Ryan Nash: Hey. Good morning, JB. Good morning, Jen. Jeff Brown: Hi, Ryan. Jen LaClair: Hi, Ryan. Ryan Nash: So, JB, you outlined in the slides 16% to 18% plus returns in 2022 and the medium-term, I think, Jen said, two years to three years and beyond, and I wanted to maybe focus on the plus. So can you maybe just talk about, some of the assumptions that are underlying, maybe give us a little bit more color? And maybe what are some of the sources of upside that we could see over the next one year to two years that are not baked into the 16% to 18%? Jeff Brown: Sure. Jen, you want to take it or, I mean, a few I will start with Ryan, and then, Jen, can go through the details. Obviously, I mean, you would look at our levels of reserves, relative to the levels of loss expectations and I think our guidance on credit, I think, you see, we’ve taken a very pragmatic and gradual normalization to credit, but that would be certainly a big one. And then, obviously, used car prices, I think, Jen, has guided, we see them within our financial plan is moderating. But I think if you look at current trends, you look at the environment, I mean, used car prices are still really strong. And as Jen pointed out, we are seeing some very modest uptick in inventory levels. But our outlook, I think, this year is a really robust used car market. So, I mean, those are a couple. Jen’s obviously got all the details behind it, but we feel really good about the outlook. Jen LaClair: Yeah. JB, I think, you nailed it. The only thing I would add is just around gains and in our insurance portfolio, we’ve been able to optimize our equity market activity and drive outside gains and so that potentially Ryan could be another area of upside. But I think you’re asking the right question. I think there’s an asymmetric bias here towards the outperforming the 16% to 18% plus and it’s past events here as reserves, these used vehicle pricing that JB hit on, plus our ability to generate gains. Ryan Nash: Got it. And Jen, if I could just dig into the expectations for the upper threes net interest margin, can you maybe just flesh out some of the assumptions that are underlying this in terms of, your assumptions on rates, your ability to drive price in the loan book? And I guess, more importantly, what are the expectations over that timeframe for deposit betas, just given you guys have obviously done a great job building the liquidity on the balance sheet and I’m wondering, can we end up seeing you exceed prior cycles, just given all the work that you guys have done on the deposit side? Thanks. Jen LaClair: Yeah. Sure. And I will start first on the yields and then go to liabilities. But on asset yields, 90% plus of our retail auto portfolio was originated at 7% plus yields. And so we are expecting, Ryan, to continued to see retail auto yields continue to migrate up towards that 7% plus. And then if rates continue to increase as we’re expecting, that could potentially go even higher. We also have floating rate assets as we’re growing floor plan. JB mentioned, we’re starting to see some increases in floor plan. Those are floating rate assets. They would migrate higher as rates increase. We’ve increased our asset sensitivity just through pay-fixed hedging activity kind of maxed out our hedging, which will also give us some tailwind. So, net-net, when we wrap this all up, plus Fair Square, Ally Lending, we see a really robust trajectory ahead on asset yields, in particular, if we see rising rates. And then on the liability side, both mix and deposits will help us. We have a much healthier liability stack having run-off, expensive high cost unsecured debt, our deposit levels are 89% of funding, and then, when you look at the value we’re providing to our customers based on products, our digital platforms and the fact that we’re core funded now, we do think, Ryan, to your questions, specifically around deposit pricing, that overall rate paid will be lower in this next rising rate cycle. So, you wrap it all up in the first couple of pages, the transformation we’ve led, the product capability expansion and the asset side, the transformation of our funding profile, it positions us so well to hit that upper 3% NIM, irrespective of the rate environment and to your question, gives us opportunity to outperform as well. Ryan Nash: Thanks for taking my questions. Jen LaClair: Yeah. Jeff Brown: Thanks, Ryan. Jen LaClair: Thanks, Ryan. Operator: Thank you. Our next question comes from the line of Bill Carcache from Wolfe Research. Your line is now open. Bill Carcache: Thank you. Good morning, JB and Jen. Jeff Brown: Hi. Good morning, Bill. Jen LaClair: Hi, Bill. Bill Carcache: Can you discuss the trajectory that you’re expecting for NIM, particularly in light of changes in fed funds and all the moving parts? The guidance on the slide is super helpful, but maybe just a little bit of color and directionally should we be expecting 2023 NIM to be normalizing higher, lower versus 2022? Jen LaClair: Yeah. Sure. And I am going to jump in here. And we’ve been guiding towards NIM expansion now for years. So if you take a step back, this has been a guide irrespective of the rate trajectory and it’s all the things I just described, Ryan, around the transformation of our asset side of balance sheet, as well as our liability stack. And so, Bill, we are expecting NIM to expand irrespective of rates. That said, in a raising -- rising rate environment, we do think that there’s an accelerated opportunity to expand earning asset yields. Just walk through some of the drivers there around floating rate assets, growing floor plan at the right time, adding short duration assets sensitive assets, like, Ally Lending and Fair Square, that will all give us growing momentum in a rising rate environment to continue to see earning asset yield expansion. And then on the liability side, the healthier staff we have, lots of that that we’re so well positioned from customer brand, engagement, digital capabilities, we do think that we will be able to hold funding costs much better in this rate environment or rising rate environments than the last one. And so that will fuel that trajectory into 2022 and allow us to sustain it into 2023 and beyond. So that’s some of the dynamics there, Bill, and hopefully that helps to answer your question. Bill Carcache: Yeah. Jen LaClair: This is not… Bill Carcache: Yeah. Jen LaClair: … a rate driven NIM expansion. This is all about structural improvements and transformation. Bill Carcache: Got it. That’s helpful. And then, separately as a follow up, can you speak to the trajectory of the reserve rate and how you’re thinking about growth in that dynamics as you grow the card business, the fact that you’re starting off the year above your day one level should help dampen those headwinds? And then sort of tacking on to that, as the card business grows, given sort of that’s a higher loss content business or should there be some expectation that at some point you would raise your capital -- your target capital expectations, if you could just touch on that? Thank you. Jen LaClair: Yeah. Sure. And on the overall reserve, it’s largely driven by retail autos. Let me start there and I will go to some of the smaller portfolios. But retail auto right now is at 3.54%. Day one was at 3.34%. So we’re running 20 basis points ahead of day one. And I think that, to JB’s point and his prepared remarks really helps us to manage through any kind of economic cycle that we could see ahead. But if you look at the path of normalization our past history, we would expect over time as NCOs normalized that, that rate would come down from the 3.54% somewhere closer to that 3.34%. So I think if anything, Bill, that gives us some tailwind heading into 2022 and 2023. And then on some of the newer products that, we will have higher coverage levels, I think, we’re very well reserve there. Fair Square, we just put on it a 12% coverage ratio. Ally Lending is close to that. So I think we’re just in a really good spot there. Not going to drive upside, but we will be growing that and the mix may change a slightly higher consolidated level. But if you wrap it all up with retail auto being as big as it is, with as high our reserve coverage level from a consolidated perspective that should come down over time. And then on our capitol target, look, we feel that we are very well positioned. We are adding some new portfolios with Fair Square and Ally Lending, but they are about $2 billion today and we will grow to $2 billion to $4 billion from here, but it’s not a big enough percent of our portfolio to really revisit the 9% target. And then also keep in mind, we’re holding 9% against a floor plan balance that is relatively risk free. So we feel really good Bill about our 9% CET1 target. Bill Carcache: That’s very helpful. Thank you for taking my questions. Jen LaClair: Thank you, of course. Operator: Thank you. Our next question comes from the line of Betsy Graseck from Morgan Stanley. Your line is now open. Betsy Graseck: Hi. Good morning. Jeff Brown: Hey. Good morning, Betsy. Jen LaClair: Hi, Betsy. Betsy Graseck: A couple of questions here, first, as we’re thinking about the Fair Square integration getting behind you, can you give us a sense as to the timing and the size that you’re going to be thinking about in terms of expanding that portfolio and what the levers are to affecting that? Jen LaClair: Yeah. Sure. So we are at about $950 billion in balances today and we see a past medium-term to $2 billion to $3 billion, Betsy, and I think, if anything, they’ve shown an ability to really accelerate those customer growth and balance sheet growth, both are up over 60% year-over-year and the balances are running 25% ahead of just the projections that we shared with you in October. So they’re seeing a really robust growth trajectory. We’re right now seeing kind of a past to $2 billion to $3 billion, but we will continue to monitor and take it from there. Betsy Graseck: And that’s obviously -- sorry, go ahead. Jen LaClair: Yeah. I mean, it’s just very compelling customer segment and product focus that is allowing them to continue to grow. And I just find out that they grew during one of the toughest credit card markets in history as we navigated COVID. Betsy Graseck: So that piece of the portfolio expanding clearly net positive to NIM. Floor plan is a little bit of a lower NIM contributor and I know in the past, you’ve talked about funding that via securities to help keep the NIM moving higher. How much room is there in that piece of security shift in floor plan? I’m asking a question from the context of your guide for upper 3% NIM. What keeps you from seeing that guide move into low 4%s, as these piece parts are coming through here? Jen LaClair: Yeah. Sure. And Betsy, we obviously have upside from floor plan and it’s on a couple of different dimensions. One is the supporting readout. But so as short-term rates increase that will naturally migrate the yield up. And second, to your point on funding, we’re reallocating cash into floor plan. So that gives us another tailwind from a mix perspective. And as I mentioned earlier, in response to Ryan’s question, there’s a lot of opportunity for earning asset yield to continue to migrate higher, plus the fact that we think we’re very well positioned to manage liability costs down. So there is an opportunity to go to that 4% plus. It’s just we tried to provide balanced guidance as we look forward, but certainly there’s upside opportunity there. Betsy Graseck: And then separately on the outlook here for used car values, which does feed into a couple of parts of the income statement. How should we think about, what you’ve got here the modeling 15% plus declined by year end 2023, like? Is that -- how did you come -- how did you get to that assessment in the guide? And what kind of pace are you thinking about that coming through the model? Jen LaClair: Yeah. Sure. And let me hit on model and then reality. Betsy Graseck: Yeah. Jen LaClair: We’ve modeled a straight line reduction from 2021 to 2023, down 15% to 20%. I think if we look at pace of used vehicle values, that continues to increase, and so the reality is, there’s probably upside to that. But again, we’re trying to give you kind of a run rate view of returns. And we will be opportunistic around upside if we were certainly in 2021 here, but the model just assumed kind of straight line reduction there. And then, another factor I’d call your attention to, because there’s so much focus on used vehicle values. As we exited 2021, the lessee buyout and the dealer buyout was increasing to 60%, 70%, 80% and so that’s muted our ability to harvest gains. It lowers the year-over-year comp as we head into 2022. So just keep that in mind. It’s not quite as big of fallout as I think some folks are modeling at this point in time. And then the last thing I’d say on used vehicle values is, we do have natural hedges, just as we had a hedge with floor plan coming down, used vehicle values going up and impacting lease yields positively. We have the hedge on the reverse, right? So as lease yields come down, we will see floor plan growing and you get all the great dynamics around putting cash to work, floating rate asset increasing. So just keep that in mind that there’s positive hedges as used vehicle values come down just like there was as they went up. Betsy Graseck: Got it. Thanks, Jen. Thanks, JB. Jen LaClair: Yeah. Thank you, Becky. Jeff Brown: Thanks, Betsy. Operator: Thank you. Our next question comes from the line of Moshe Orenbuch from CS. Your line is now open. Moshe Orenbuch: Hey. Thanks. Thanks very much. And you’ve had -- you alluded to this in the opening comments, but you’ve got a better loan growth than you’ve had in a while both you’ve got reasonable growth in retail auto and then kind of grows across the portfolios. Can you talk about how that is likely to trend over the next year or two and then I’ve got a follow up? Thanks. Jen LaClair: Yeah. Sure, Moshe. And I mentioned assets getting to $200 billion and -- in our medium-term and that’s driven by all the portfolios, you just mentioned, I mean, retail auto, we were originating at mid-$30 billion, we had $46.3 billion this year, we’re guiding towards low $40 billion. And so as we continue to see opportunities to originate at a higher level that will obviously take our retail portfolio higher. Also seeing strong growth in lease as well, floor plans, obviously, come back. We saw kind of trough in September and steady growth from there, and I think it will be a little choppy from here on out, we will see, but definitely opportunities in floor plan to come back. And then the unsecured capabilities that we’ve recently added with Ally Lending, with Fair Square, each of those portfolios could get to $2 billion to $3 billion over time. And then last but not least, we’ve seen really nice opportunities to originate in mortgage, we put forward kind of our $10 billion target into this year and we will see how that plays out. But we really like our capabilities and we’ve expanded into new markets with mortgage systems and growth opportunities there. And floor plan continues to be a steady driver. We always talked about, I’m sorry, corporate finance always tends to be a steady driver, we’ve talked about $8 billion to $10 billion in that portfolio. We already hit $8 billion, I think, well on our way to $10 billion, as you look at the total opportunity in that segment. And then we will put cash to work and securities as well. So really across the Board, Moshe, we see really nice tailwinds and opportunities to grow, in addition to the NIM expansion that we’ve been talking about this morning. Moshe Orenbuch: Great. Right. And your medium-term kind of forecast talks about PPNR expansion on an annual basis. One of the concerns that investors have had about financials after the reports in the big banks has been expense growth. Can you kind of talk about your plans, because obviously, PPNR expansion means that your revenues got to grow faster than expenses, but just talk about the plans for generating operating efficiencies and how you think about that, particularly in light of the context, the remarks, JB, that you made about, minimum wage, phasing that in and kind of how that will integrate into your plan over the next couple of years? Jen LaClair: Yeah. Sure. And Moshe, just as a reminder, we don’t manage kind of single line items point in time, we’ve been managing the company to drive accretive returns and we’ve been investing in growth. And what I shared with you in the first couple pages around continuing to invest in capabilities, grow customers, grow our balance sheet, grow returns, that is the focus of ours, just in general. And we’ve been investing as a growth company. We’ve seen kind of mid single-digit expense growth over the last couple years. We would expect to continue to see that. But as we’ve demonstrated in the past, we’re focused on positive operating leverage, PPNR expansion, robust return trajectory and you should expect more of that to come from a PPNR, as well as operating leverage perspective. Now, I will note that with Fair Square coming in -- into 2022, we will have one month of expenses rolling forward to 12 months. There’s some nuances there. We do see positive operating leverage as we get into 2023. But definitely just some technical impacts this year from Fair Square. But you wrap it all up, a lot of focus on expenses, but for us, it’s really around growing our businesses and growing revenue. We saw revenue up 25% this year. We have a very robust trajectory as we head into 2023 -- 2022 and 2023 and we will keep investing, but we’re -- leverage is front and center all the time. Moshe Orenbuch: Okay. Thanks so much. Jen LaClair: Yeah. Thank you, Moshe. Operator: Thank you. Our next question comes from the line of Sanjay Sakhrani from KBW. Your line is now. Sanjay Sakhrani: Thanks. Good morning. I guess I got a question on the retail auto yield. I mean, that’s -- I guess your expectations are that continues to remain strong. I’m just curious, I know a lot of it’s been driven by mix inside of retail auto. But as we think about just maybe competitive forces coming back into play, how much of a factor do you think it plays into that yield going forward over the next couple of years? Jen LaClair: Yeah, Sanjay, yeah, it’s fourth year putting strong origination flows on the books that 7% plus yields and we’re guiding towards similar performance as we head into 2022. And it’s simply a result of the growth in dealers, growth in dealer engagement, where we think we still have significant opportunity for expansion. It’s the continued investment in our capabilities, including our SmartAuction platform, insurance. And so we don’t see any signs that that will slow down as we head into 2022 and beyond. And while competition is always intense, we aren’t seeing that interrupt our flows are -- impact our performance whatsoever as we head into 2022 and beyond. Jeff Brown: And Sanjay, just -- obviously, remind our number one lender in the prime space, one of the largest used lenders. And to get that type of performance, you need to have significant scale, which is something we bring. And so, I think, we’re large, we’re fast, the dealers like us. We’ve automated a lot of our risk-based decisions, so we respond very quickly. So, yes, we recognize, there are players come and go, but I think the one thing what dealers appreciate about Ally is our stability and that’s part of the -- have been one of the big drivers why we continue to see a big uptick in origination flows and what, Jen, just guided even into the low $40 billions is pretty strong loan growth year-on-year. Sanjay Sakhrani: No. Absolutely. You guys have executed really well. I guess, maybe another question on competition and follows along some of the questions that Moshe was asking in terms of expenses. In the -- on the consumer lending side that that targeted growth that you expect for Fair Square, I mean, like, is that just more direct marketing, and therefore, there shouldn’t be a significant ramp up in marketing spend, because we’ve heard the big banks, as well as some of the card issuers talk about ramping up expenses to get new accounts. I’m just curious sort of how you expect to go-to-market there and do you expect some pressure on expenses as you build that business out? And how does it factor into the growth that you’re expecting? Jen LaClair: Yeah. And I think, Fair Square is a bit unique. It’s similar to what JB just mentioned on auto. It’s kind of a unique product for a unique market. They’re originating in that time space, which is not nearly as competed as the super prime space and so the direct marketing that they’ve been doing has been highly effective as reflected in the 60% plus increase in customer accounts, as well as the growth in the balance sheet. And all of the expenses attached to that are in the really robust guidance I’ve provided, which is kind of immediately accretive from our ROTC perspective, it will be accretive from an EPS perspective by year end this year and it will drive operating leverage as we head into 2023. So you can see that our investments are paying off from a growth and profitability perspective. And I think if anything, we can turbo charge that growth by bringing them in inside the four walls of Ally and leveraging our existing customer base, Sanjay, which is not going to require significant additions to our marketing spend. Sanjay Sakhrani: And how much of that is factor, like, is this cross-sell a big part of the growth expectation or is that just benefit? Jen LaClair: Yeah. Sanjay Sakhrani: Benefit? Jen LaClair: None of that, Sanjay, is built into any of the numbers that we share. That will be all upside. And again, it will be driven by synergies across our platform much more so than increase in marketing. Sanjay Sakhrani: Okay. Jeff Brown: Sanjay, I mean, I would point out, though, what sometimes cross-sell gets knocked and the question of, can you really do it? I think, I mean, if you look at our growth and multi-product relationships, it shows we are actually one of the banks that’s executing in that regard. And so while we don’t necessarily have it embedded in the guidance, I think, that’s a clear focus point for us. So how do we use the cross-sell of a massive customer base? I mean, if you think of kind of another 9.5 million customers ex credit card, is even bigger than that existed Ally. That is an opportunity that we will go after. Sanjay Sakhrani: Great. Thank you. Jen LaClair: Thank you, Sanjay. Operator: Our next question comes from the line of Arren Cyganovich from Citi. Your line is now open. Arren Cyganovich: Thanks. Maybe not to stay on card for too much, but the -- it is kind of an exciting new area for you. But what’s the strategy for 2022, are you going to rebrand to Ally? Are you going to go up market a little bit or are you just going to kind of let them operate under that Fair Square brand for the near-term? Jen LaClair: Yeah. And -- thank you. And we agree it’s an exciting opportunity. And the short answer here is, we’re going to let them continue to execute the way they’ve been executing over the last five years. It’s been a tremendous product, growth story for them and we don’t want to interrupt the execution on that front. In parallel, we are looking to rebrand their cards. We will do so by year end. And we do think that there’s product expansion opportunities as we just talked about over time, but that’s going to be something we grow into as we think about the broader Ally customer ecosystem. And then last but not least, just a huge shout out to that team. It’s just been a tremendous experience bringing them on Board. They know what they’re doing. They’ve got decades of experience in card and we couldn’t be more excited about the team products, the opportunity ahead in the card space. Arren Cyganovich: Great. And then, just lastly, the -- there’s been, excuse me, a little bit of concern about credit in the personal installment loan space with a lot of new entrants into the market. What are you seeing within Ally Lending on the credit side? Jen LaClair: Yeah. I mean, I would point to our performance, which has been robust. I think it’s a large. It’s a rapidly growing market. So there’s no surprise that there’s new entrants in that space. But we feel really well positioned, especially in the verticals where we’re focused home improvement, healthcare are dominant areas for us. We’ve continued to be able to grow merchants in that spaces, as well as originations and balances. So, we’re not surprised that there’s some new entrants, but we feel really good about our products and our performance. And just as a reminder, we’re not kind of BNPL, the paying for product, that’s getting a lot of scrutiny across the industry, just in terms of consumer-oriented practices. This is a traditional installment product. We go through traditional credit underwriting. We have robust credit risk management around this product. So feel great about the opportunity ahead. Daniel Eller: Okay. Thanks. Thanks, Jen, and to all the participants. That concludes today’s calls. We’re at the top of the hour here. Operator, you may now take us through the disconnect process. Operator: This concludes today’s conference. Thank you for participating. You may now disconnect.
ALLY Ratings Summary
ALLY Quant Ranking
Related Analysis

Ally Financial Inc. (NYSE:ALLY) Faces Market Challenges and Opportunities

  • The consensus price target for Ally Financial Inc. (NYSE:ALLY) has decreased from $41.88 to $40, indicating a slight bearish sentiment among analysts.
  • Despite a predicted decline in earnings for the upcoming quarter, analyst David Long from Raymond James sets an optimistic price target of $50, suggesting potential growth.
  • The Federal Reserve's decision to lower interest rates could positively impact Ally's financial performance, potentially benefiting earnings.

Ally Financial Inc. (NYSE:ALLY) is a digital financial-services company that provides a variety of financial products and services to consumers, commercial entities, and corporate customers, mainly in the United States and Canada. The company operates through four main segments: Automotive Finance Operations, Insurance Operations, Mortgage Finance Operations, and Corporate Finance Operations.

Over the past year, the consensus price target for Ally has seen a slight decline. A year ago, analysts had a higher average target price of $41.88, which has decreased to $40 in the most recent month. This downward trend may reflect changing market conditions, company performance, or shifts in analyst sentiment regarding the company's future prospects. Despite this, analyst David Long from Raymond James has set a price target of $50, indicating potential growth prospects.

Ally is set to report its third-quarter earnings this Friday. Analysts are predicting a decline in earnings for the company in its upcoming report, as highlighted by Zacks. This report will be crucial in determining the stock's future trajectory amidst the current market conditions. Investors are evaluating whether the stock should be considered for their portfolios, especially with concerns over asset quality.

Ally experienced financial pressure when interest rates began to climb. However, with the Federal Reserve now lowering interest rates, the bank is expected to benefit from an earnings boost. This change in interest rates could positively impact Ally's financial performance, potentially aligning with David Long's optimistic price target of $50 for the stock.

While specific news articles or reports were not provided, changes in consensus price targets often correlate with company earnings reports, strategic business decisions, or broader economic factors. Investors should consider these elements when evaluating the stock's potential and consult recent news releases or financial reports for more detailed insights.

Ally Financial Stock in Tactical Outperform List at Evercore

Evercore ISI analysts maintained their In Line rating and a price target of $30.00 on Ally Financial (NYSE:ALLY). However, they now included the stock in the Tactical Outperform List due to its apparent oversold condition in the short term.

The analysts explained that Ally Financial's fundamental prospects and valuation have been negatively affected by various factors, including challenging interest rate conditions (yield challenges and funding pressures), a decline in consumer credit quality, and the anticipated effects of TLAC (Total Loss-Absorbing Capacity) and B3EG (Basel III Enhanced Leverage Ratio) on returns.

Nevertheless, the analysts believe that recent efforts to control expense growth, combined with the stabilization or potential improvement in used car values, could lead to short-term upside potential for the stock, which is currently trading at a discounted valuation.

Ally Financial Shares Plunge 5% Following Q1 EPS Miss

Ally Financial (NYSE:ALLY) shares fell more than 5% intra-day today after the company reported its Q1 results, with EPS of $0.82 missing the Street estimate of $0.86. Revenue came in at $2.1 billion, better than the Street estimate of $2.07 billion.

Net financing revenue decreased 4.3% sequentially to $1.6 billion as higher earning assets were offset by a 14 bps sequential decline in the margin to 3.51%. Earning asset yields increased 47 bps sequentially to 6.71%, while funding costs increased 66 bps to 3.39%.

Management remains confident in the trajectory of earnings over time, though navigating near-term margin, funding, and credit dynamics remains the focus.

Ally Financial Shares Surge 23% Since Q4 Earnings Release

Ally Financial (NYSE:ALLY) shares gained more than 23% since the company’s reported Q4 results on Friday morning, with EPS of $1.08 coming in better than the Street estimate of $0.97. Revenue was $2.2 billion, beating the Street estimate of $2.06 billion.

Although normalization in retail auto credit and deposit pricing is accelerating and causes investor concerns, management expressed confidence that as these dynamics stabilize.

Management is optimistic that the margin can trough at approximately 3.50% in 2023, and with asset repricing tailwinds, can improve to 3.75%-4.00% in 2024.