Stock Appreciation Rights: Gem Of Employee Compensation

Image Source: Navi

A Stock Appreciation Right (SAR) grants individuals the entitlement to receive compensation proportional to the rise in the company's common stock price compared to a base value or the appreciation of the equity shares currently traded on the public market. They represent a deferred incentive for employees, disbursed when the company's stock value exceeds the option exercise price. Functioning akin to stock options, they confer upon holders the right to obtain an amount equivalent to the surplus of the optioned shares' market value within a defined timeframe. Nonetheless, these diverge from stock options as employees receive the same benefits without the need for a cash outlay associated with purchasing the option.

Understanding Stock Appreciation Rights

In essence, these afford holders the privilege to benefit from the increase in market value of shares over a specified period. The program establishes a vesting schedule for each employee, dictating when they can exercise their rights. This setup links SARs to performance objectives outlined by the company. Employers may issue these in conjunction with stock options, aiding employees in generating funds to cover the exercise price. Thus, these are often considered alongside stock options. If employees anticipate that their efforts will impact the future trajectory of the stock's market value, these can serve as a motivational tool. Consequently, they function as a type of incentive compensation and as a safeguard during liquidity events. They are commonly sanctioned within stock option plans because, as tandem SARs, they serve as a crucial mechanism to assist employees in financing the payment of stock options and taxes on any taxable gains.

Key Features of Stock Appreciation Rights

No Out-of-Pocket Expense

Unlike stock options, these do not require employees to purchase shares at a predetermined price. This feature makes them particularly attractive to employees who may not have the financial resources to exercise stock options.

Cash or Stock Settlement

They can be settled in cash, company stock, or a combination of both, providing flexibility to both the employer and the employee, thus suiting all types of risk tolerance.

Alignment of Interests

They align the interests of employees with those of shareholders by tying compensation directly to the company's stock price performance. This incentivizes employees to contribute to the company's growth and success.

No Dilution of Ownership

Since these do not involve the issuance of new shares, they do not dilute existing shareholders' ownership stakes in the company.

Vesting Schedule

These typically have a vesting schedule, meaning employees must remain with the company for a certain period before they can exercise their rights. This helps incentivize employee retention and loyalty.

How Stock Appreciation Rights Function

Image Source: eqvista.medium.com

These possess transferability and are subject to a clawback policy, which delineates triggering events enabling a company to reclaim employees' bonuses or any other incentive-based compensation, irrespective of whether the provision is applied retrospectively or with future effect. For instance, the policy might authorize a company to revoke them if an employee transitions to a competitor before the expiration of their employment contract. Additionally, akin to stock options, the settlement date may lack a predetermined schedule, affording employees flexibility in timing the exercise of their rights. Most programs are linked to the achievement of company objectives, such as profit or sales targets.

A Practical Example

Consider that a limited firm issued stock appreciation rights on January 1, 2014, when the stock price stood at $100 per share, with the vesting date set for January 1, 2024. Suppose a person named John received SARs for 20 shares of ABC Limited. Assuming the company's stock price on the vesting date is $900, the in-the-money value of John's rights is $16,000 [($900 $100) x 20]. John has the option to settle them either in cash for $16,000 or in the firm's shares, equivalent to 17 shares ($16,000/$900).

Tax Treatment of Stock Appreciation Rights

These typically undergo the same tax treatment as non-qualified stock options (NSOs). Employers are responsible for managing the administrative duties of withholding taxes and remitting them to the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). However, individuals granted solely stock options encounter several drawbacks. These include the need to generate funds for exercising the stock option, covering stockbroker commissions on trades, paying taxes on the employee benefits and gains, and facing the risk of a decline in the underlying stock's market price. Companies can mitigate potential cash shortfalls by awarding them alongside stock options. These rights furnish the necessary cash to address various financial outflows.

Pros and Cons of Stock Appreciation Rights

Image Source: sorryonmute.com

These plans present numerous advantages compared to other types of stock compensation. One benefit is the receipt of cash benefits without the requirement of upfront payment to exercise options. Another advantage is the ability to customize them to suit the recipient's needs. Companies implementing these plans can determine which employees receive benefits, the liquidity of SARs, bonus values, and optimal vesting rules. These serve as a motivational tool for employees, offering additional incentives linked to a company's performance, thereby aiding in employee motivation and reducing turnover rates. Furthermore, they entail less complex accounting regulations than other forms of stock compensation. Employees also find them appealing due to the absence of preferential taxation associated with qualified stock options. On the flip side, tandem SARs might negatively impact a company's share value, similar to straight stock options, as they increase outstanding shares, potentially diluting per-share earnings.

Special Considerations

SARs and phantom stocks exhibit several notable parallels. Phantom stock entails an agreement granting an employee a cash payment corresponding to the rise in stock price at a specified time. Employees receiving phantom stock options incur income taxes at the ordinary income rate. Similarly, stock options undergo comparable tax treatment as ordinary income and are subject to taxation.

Conclusion

Stock Appreciation Rights represent a dynamic and increasingly popular form of employee compensation that aligns the interests of employees with those of shareholders. Offering flexibility, motivation, and alignment of interests, they are a valuable tool for companies seeking to attract, retain, and incentivize top talent in today's competitive business environment. As the landscape of employee compensation, such as SARs and Employee Stock Purchase Plans, continues to evolve, these are likely to remain a prominent feature in companies' incentive programs, driving employee engagement and contributing to long-term growth and success.